Discussion Guide: Reimagining Christmas
Desired Takeaway
We can rethink how we celebrate Christmas because what makes Christmas wonderful has never changed: God has come near to us in Jesus.
Our traditions, expectations, and celebrations shape us, often in ways we don't recognize. The goal is to examine what we're being formed to value during Christmas and consider how we might celebrate in ways that cultivate gratitude, generosity, presence, and love.
Christmas isn't something wonderful we have to create. At its heart, it's something wonderful God has already done.
Discussion Questions
1. Lean In
We all carry an idea of what Christmas should look and feel like. Those expectations are shaped by our childhoods, families, experiences, and the culture around us.
2. Look Down
Read John 1:9–14.
John describes the wonder of Christmas not through familiar images of shepherds, angels, and a manger, but through the astonishing reality that God entered our world and made his home among us.
3. Look Out
Christmas traditions aren't necessarily good or bad in themselves. The same tradition can cultivate generosity or greed, gratitude or comparison, meaningful connection or exhausting expectations.
4. Look In
Sometimes the pressure we feel during Christmas reveals something deeper about our expectations and desires. We may be longing for connection, belonging, joy, peace, or a sense that everything is okay.
5. Live It Out
We don't have to abandon the traditions we love or create an entirely new Christmas. But we can become more intentional about how we celebrate and what those celebrations are cultivating in us.
Optional Exercises for the Week
1. Reimagine Your Traditions
Before the Christmas season gets underway, sit down with your spouse, family, or a friend and talk about your Christmas traditions.
Ask:
2. Practice Presence
Choose one moment this week to slow down and be fully present with someone.
Put away your phone. Let go of the need to accomplish something. Listen, enjoy their company, and be grateful for the gift of being together.
Reflect afterward: What changes when I stop trying to create a meaningful moment and simply become present to the one I'm already in?
3. Make Room for Generosity
Think of one way to redirect some of your Christmas spending, time, or energy toward someone who might otherwise be overlooked.
It might mean blessing a family in need, including someone who would otherwise be alone, or giving a thoughtful gift that communicates genuine love.
Ask: "How can the generosity of God become more visible through the way I celebrate Christmas?"
Prayer Prompt
Invite the group to reflect on the expectations they're carrying into Christmas. Are there pressures, anxieties, or disappointments they need to bring before Jesus?
Father, thank you for the incredible gift of coming near to us in Jesus. Remind us that the wonder of Christmas isn't something we have to manufacture, but something you've already given us.
Help us recognize the ways our habits and expectations are shaping our hearts. Free us from comparison, unnecessary pressure, and the constant desire for more.
Teach us to celebrate with gratitude, generosity, joy, and love. Help us be present to you and to the people around us. And for those carrying grief or disappointment this season, may your presence bring comfort and hope.
May the way we celebrate Christmas help us become more like Jesus.
Amen.
Suggested Resources for Further Study
The Ruthless Elimination of Hurry — John Mark Comer
Explores how busyness, distraction, and consumerism shape our souls, and how following Jesus invites us into a different rhythm of life.
Advent Conspiracy — Rick McKinley, Chris Seay, and Greg Holder
Offers a practical vision for celebrating Christmas through worship, generosity, simplicity, and loving others.
We can rethink how we celebrate Christmas because what makes Christmas wonderful has never changed: God has come near to us in Jesus.
Our traditions, expectations, and celebrations shape us, often in ways we don't recognize. The goal is to examine what we're being formed to value during Christmas and consider how we might celebrate in ways that cultivate gratitude, generosity, presence, and love.
Christmas isn't something wonderful we have to create. At its heart, it's something wonderful God has already done.
Discussion Questions
1. Lean In
We all carry an idea of what Christmas should look and feel like. Those expectations are shaped by our childhoods, families, experiences, and the culture around us.
- When you picture a truly wonderful Christmas, what comes to mind? Where do you think that picture came from, and how has it changed over the years?
- Optional follow-up: Have you ever experienced a Christmas that was wonderful for reasons you didn't expect?
2. Look Down
Read John 1:9–14.
John describes the wonder of Christmas not through familiar images of shepherds, angels, and a manger, but through the astonishing reality that God entered our world and made his home among us.
- What stands out to you about the way John describes God coming into the world? What does the incarnation reveal about God's character and his desire for a relationship with humanity?
- Optional follow-up: How might seeing Christmas primarily as something God has done for us, rather than something we need to create, change the way we experience the season?
3. Look Out
Christmas traditions aren't necessarily good or bad in themselves. The same tradition can cultivate generosity or greed, gratitude or comparison, meaningful connection or exhausting expectations.
- When you look at how our culture celebrates Christmas, what do you think we're being taught about what makes life wonderful? How might those messages be shaping us, especially our children, in ways we don't recognize?
- Optional follow-up: Where have you seen Christmas traditions genuinely cultivate love, generosity, gratitude, or meaningful relationships?
4. Look In
Sometimes the pressure we feel during Christmas reveals something deeper about our expectations and desires. We may be longing for connection, belonging, joy, peace, or a sense that everything is okay.
- As you think about the upcoming Christmas season, what are you most hoping to experience? What happens inside you when you imagine Christmas not living up to those expectations?
- Optional follow-up: Are there any traditions, expectations, or activities you hold on to because you're afraid of what Christmas might feel like without them?
5. Live It Out
We don't have to abandon the traditions we love or create an entirely new Christmas. But we can become more intentional about how we celebrate and what those celebrations are cultivating in us.
- If you approached this Christmas with the goal of becoming more grateful, generous, present, and loving, rather than simply creating wonderful experiences, what might you do differently? What might you keep, change, or let go of?
- Optional follow-up: What is one intentional choice you could make this Christmas that would help you or the people around you experience more of the love and presence of Jesus?
Optional Exercises for the Week
1. Reimagine Your Traditions
Before the Christmas season gets underway, sit down with your spouse, family, or a friend and talk about your Christmas traditions.
Ask:
- Which traditions bring us genuine joy and connection?
- Which ones create unnecessary stress, comparison, or pressure?
- What might we change this year to make more room for Jesus and the people we love?
2. Practice Presence
Choose one moment this week to slow down and be fully present with someone.
Put away your phone. Let go of the need to accomplish something. Listen, enjoy their company, and be grateful for the gift of being together.
Reflect afterward: What changes when I stop trying to create a meaningful moment and simply become present to the one I'm already in?
3. Make Room for Generosity
Think of one way to redirect some of your Christmas spending, time, or energy toward someone who might otherwise be overlooked.
It might mean blessing a family in need, including someone who would otherwise be alone, or giving a thoughtful gift that communicates genuine love.
Ask: "How can the generosity of God become more visible through the way I celebrate Christmas?"
Prayer Prompt
Invite the group to reflect on the expectations they're carrying into Christmas. Are there pressures, anxieties, or disappointments they need to bring before Jesus?
Father, thank you for the incredible gift of coming near to us in Jesus. Remind us that the wonder of Christmas isn't something we have to manufacture, but something you've already given us.
Help us recognize the ways our habits and expectations are shaping our hearts. Free us from comparison, unnecessary pressure, and the constant desire for more.
Teach us to celebrate with gratitude, generosity, joy, and love. Help us be present to you and to the people around us. And for those carrying grief or disappointment this season, may your presence bring comfort and hope.
May the way we celebrate Christmas help us become more like Jesus.
Amen.
Suggested Resources for Further Study
The Ruthless Elimination of Hurry — John Mark Comer
Explores how busyness, distraction, and consumerism shape our souls, and how following Jesus invites us into a different rhythm of life.
Advent Conspiracy — Rick McKinley, Chris Seay, and Greg Holder
Offers a practical vision for celebrating Christmas through worship, generosity, simplicity, and loving others.
